July 23, 2012  

The Punter is King but now dethroned!

In May I wrote a BLOG called “The Punter is King” and in it I included the following two paragraphs:

“This is very apparent in the Wandsworth example of the Springfield Hospital development site. This large, undeveloped, NHS site has stood under-used for decades. The NHS, which of course needs the money, has put forward two perfectly acceptable development proposals, but they got their politics wrong. Their last application was submitted at a time when it got caught up in the 2010 General Election. Both major parties, for largely electoral reasons, took part in a vigorous anti-campaign and the Council, assisted by the fact that its Deputy Leader lived opposite the site, decided to reject the application.

The community, or rather the immediate neighbours, knew what it wanted and won the argument – the Council gave the punters their desires. But just what are the odds on a semi-privatised NHS, even more strapped for cash, and/or its developers coming back with a larger, much less neighbour friendly application – fair to middling I guess – and in the meantime we have had an extra few years of decay, fewer desperately needed homes and less money for the health service. So we have total victory for the punters in the short-term but arguably a loss for the wider community (the homeless and patients) and a probable long-term loss.”

Well, now the Secretary of State has taken the matter into his own hands and granted planning permisson and both the local Labour MP, Sadiq Khan, and the local Tory Council, Wandsworth Borough Council, have joined together in condemning the decision. But what actually is the result? The development is much as Wandsworth Council officers originally recommended, with very much the same conditions applied. As it happens the delay was not perhaps as great as I had feared and it is not the case that a worse scheme has been put forward by an even more cash-strapped NHS.

Does it merely prove that we are all Nimbies (from Nimby or Not In My Back Yard) and that big local planning issues cannot be left to local authorities – sad, if true.

Unknown's avatar

About Tony Belton

Labour Councillor for Latchmere Ward 1972-2022, now Battersea Park Ward, London Borough of Wandsworth Ever hopeful Spurs supporter; Lane visit to the Lane, 1948 Olympics. Why don't they simply call the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, The Lane? Once understood IT but no longer

Leave a comment